Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit June 19, 1964, 14634 (Walter Sowizral v. Mrs. Adele M. Hughes)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-06-1964

FORMAN, Circuit Judge.

Plaintiff Walter Sowizral (hereafter appellant), a citizen of Canada, has appealed the verdict of a jury in his negligence suit that favored defendant Adele M. Hughes (hereafter appellee), a citizen of Pennsylvania.

1

The essence of his complaint alleged that while sitting in a non-moving automobile, he suffered injuries as a result of being struck by an automobile negligently operated by ap-pellee. She answered denying negligence. At the trial a jury returned a verdict favoring appellee. The United States District Court for the Middle Dis-

*831

triet of Pennsylvania, in an unreported memorandum, refused a motion for new trial.

The gist of appellant’s argument here is that the charge of the District Court was fundamentally incorrect. Appellee asserts that not only was the charge correct, but that appellant made no specific objections at the time of trial to the points he now raises.

“The testimony in this ease,” the District Court stated in its memorandum on the motion for a new trial, “presented a mass of conflict, much more than occurs in the ordinary case.” After resolving all reasonable inferences from the evidence most strongly against the appellant, as required at this stage,

2

the pertinent facts are as follows:

Appellant and his wife had decided to drive in his automobile from their home in Toronto, Canada to Florida for a vacation. They wei'e to be accompanied by their friends, Walter Wells and his wife, also of Toronto. Accordingly, on February 12, 1959, the parties left Toronto in appellant’s car driven by him. They proceeded on that day as far as Dunean-non, Pennsylvania, where they put up for the night at a motel.

The journey was resumed early the following morning, February 13, 1959. Between 5 and 6 a. m., they were already traveling south on Route 15. Because of the darkness, rain, cold and the fear “that it would start to freeze”, appellant drove at about 15 to 20 miles an hour.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.