Ohio Court of Appeals February 4, 1964, 7508 (Durbin v. Schneider)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-1964

*367

Dueeey, J.

This is an original action in mandamus to require the respondent, Tax Commissioner, to restore the 69 relators to positions which have been purportedly abolished. Respondent has filed a general demurrer to the petition.

There is much in the petition which appears to be legally irrelevant or of no significance. There is also apparent confusion between a “layoff” and a “job abolishment.” There are extensive allegations with respect to provisional employees being certified to relators’ positions which would also appear to be immaterial. See

State, ex rel. Stine,

v.

McCaw, Chief of Div. of Aid for Aged

(1940), 137 Ohio St., 13. However, it is not this court’s function or that of a demurrer to clean up the relators’ pleadings.

Upon examination of the whole petition we find that it sufficiently alleges facts which state a cause of action. Relators held civil service positions. By a letter issued by the Tax Commissioner their jobs were abolished. Allegedly, respondent has hired persons to perform the same or similar work. Allegedly, “at least sixty-five” of the relators “were dismissed for political reasons” and in “bad faith.” Allegedly, the reasons given for abolishment,

i. e.,

reorganization and economy, are “subterfuges” for political discrimination.

There are, of course, various ways in which unemployment may result in a civil service position. It is elementary in civil service law to distinguish between the removal of an employee from the position, and the abolishment of the position itself which results in the loss of employment for the person holding that position. The removal of the employee himself from a civil service position may be by discharge, suspension, layoff, etc. Such actions are appealable to the Personnel Board of Review. See Section 143.012, Revised Code,

State, ex rel. Kendrick,

v.

Masheter, Dir., Dept. of Highways

(1963), 120 Ohio App., 168, and

State, ex rel. Kendrick,

v.

Masheter, Director of Highways

(1964), 176 Ohio St., 232.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.