District Court of Appeal of Florida February 11, 1964, No. E-354 (Walters v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-02-1964

STURGIS, Chief Judge.

The appellant, plaintiff below, appeals from a judgment on the pleadings in favor of appellee, defendant below, entered on the pleadings pursuant to Rule 1.11, Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, 30 F.S.A. The judgment contains a finding, based exclusively on the pleadings, “that no cause of action exists in favor of the Plaintiff under the policy of insurance sued upon.” We reverse.

The material and well-pleaded matters of fact supporting appellant’s claim, which facts are taken as true for the purpose of testing the judgment on the pleadings appealed, reveal that appellant is the owner of an automobile insurance policy issued to him by appellee providing sundry benefits, including indemnity against loss in the premises hereinafter mentioned; that during the term of said policy appellant was involved in an automobile accident while driving a motor vehicle owned by one Orvid Hamrick, as a result of which Hamrick brought an action for damages against appellant; that appellee breached said, insurance contract by failing and refusing to defend -appellant, the defendant in said action. Attached to the .complaint herein'is a letter from the appellee’s adjuster dated June 11, 1962, addressed to appellant, returning to appellant the summons and complaint in the action brought by Hamrick and advising appellant that under the terms of said policy the appellee owed him no defense of said suit and that no protection was afforded to him in the premises. Hamrick obtained a judgment against appellant on March 11, 1963, in the sum of approximately $800 and appellant made two written demands upon appellee to discharge the same. Appellee refused to do so and appellant thereupon brought this suit upon the policy to recover damages thus sustained for breach thereof, together with his attorney’s fees and costs herein.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.