Court of Appeals of Kentucky January 24, 1964 (Columbia Amusement Co. v. Hughes)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-01-1964
WILLIAMS, Judge.
This is an appeal from an order of the Calloway Circuit Court granting summary judgment against the appellant Columbia Amusement Company.
Columbia leased a building owned by appellee Nat Ryan Hughes which was totally destroyed by fire on December 12, 1962. Columbia maintained the lease provided that the property should be rebuilt and that the proceeds from insurance on the property should be applied to such purpose. .
At the time the lease was executed in 1938, Columbia’s president loaned Hughes’ mother $20,000.00 to remodel the building. Both Columbia and its president were named as insureds in the insurance policies covering the property. The money' was later repaid but Columbia was continued as an insured in the policies. Mrs. Hughes and Columbia’s president have since died. The lease has been renewed s.everal times and could have continued in force until 1973.
After his mother’s death Hughes borrowed $75,000.00 from appelleé Peoples Bank of Murray. The Bank was made a mortgage loss payee in the insurance policies taken on the property. The judgment of the circuit court allowed the Bank to recover the amount owed to it by Hughes out of the insurance proceeds, and directed that the remainder be paid over to Hughes.
*814A motion for summary judgment by the Bank was sufficient to authorize the judgment rendered by the circuit court. A similar motion by Hughes would have served no purpose because the motion by the Bank brought out the issues between each of the parties. See Collins v. Duff, Ky., 283 S.W.2d 179 (1955). Columbia had no conceivable claim against the insurance money unless a right somehow emanated from the fact it was leasing the property. Even though it was named as an insured in the policies the right to recover still depended on an insurable interest, if any, achieved by reason of the lease. Although summary judgment will not lie when there is a genuine issue of material fact to be determined, Petty v. Codell Construction Co., Ky.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit