Court of Appeals of Kentucky May 8, 1964 (Commonwealth, Department of Welfare, Division of Corrections v. Stevens)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-05-1964

WILLIAMS, Judge.

The Oldham Circuit Court sustained ap-pellee’s petition for habeas corpus on the ground there was no valid judgment sentencing him to the Kentucky State Reformatory. The Commonwealth has appealed, alleging first that RCr 11.42 has supplanted habeas corpus as the method to obtain post-conviction review, and secondly, that the judgment is not void.

The appellee was indicted in Pulaski Circuit Court and charged with two violations of the local option laws. On the first indictment he entered a plea of not guilty, was tried by a jury, found guilty, and his punishment fixed at two years in the penitentiary. He entered a plea of guilty on the second indictment and in that case was given two years in the penitentiary. To avoid repetition, we shall confine ourselves to the proceedings surrounding the first indictment.

On May 18, 1962, the following order, styled “Verdict and Judgment,” was entered in the Pulaski Circuit Court criminal order book:

“This day this cause came on for trial. Came the defendant Tommie Stevens by counsel Hon. H. K. Spear waived arraignment and entered a plea of not guilty to the above charge. The *800following jury was empaneled and sworn to try the case:

Oscar Whitson Martha Whiles William Burton Virgil Howard Macie Wilson E. E. McBride Richard Adams Hury Trimble Shadrack Blevins Willie McDaniel Lola Floyd Opal Spears

“The Comth’s Attorney read the indictment and stated the plea of the defendant to the jury, and the jury after hearing the evidence, and instructions of the Court retired to their jury room to deliberate, and after due deliberation returned into open court the following verdict: ‘We the jury find the defendant guilty as charged and fix his punishment at 2 years in the Pen. /s/ Willie McDaniel.’

“It is further ordered that the defendant execute a Peace Bond in amount of $1,000 if said case is appealed.

“The defendant was placed in the custody of the jailer to await the sentencing of the Court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.