Court of Appeals of Kentucky September 22, 1964 (Hulbert v. Board of Education)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-09-1964
CLAY, Commissioner.
This declaratory judgment action questions the validity of two propositions to be submitted to the voters at an election initiated by the Boards of Education of the City of Louisville and Jefferson County. The Chancellor held the questions legally sufficient.
The questions which will appear on the respective ballots are:
“Are you for or against the following combined tax authorisation for public school purposes: (a) levying in the Louisville Independent School District each year an additional general ad valorem property tax at a rate not exceeding 32‡ on each $100.00 of property subject to local taxation in said district as authorized by KRS 157.440, and, (b) imposing an annual license fee on any business, trade, occupation or profession at a rate not to exceed %oths of 1% of wages and net profts from activities conducted in said school district, as authorized under KRS 160.-531 ?” (Our emphasis)
“Are you for or against both of the following combined tax authorisations for public school purposes: (a) levying in the Jefferson County School District each year an additional general ad valorem property tax at a rate not exceeding 32‡ on each $100.00 of property subject to local taxation in said district as authorized by KRS 157.440, in addition to the presently levied $1.50 property tax rate for general school purposes, and in addition to the 50¡á Special Voted School Building Tax rate, and also (b) imposing an annual license fee on any business, trade, occupation or profession at a rate not to exceed %oths of 1% of wages and net profits from activities conducted in said school district, as authorized under KRS 160.-531 ?” (Our emphasis)
The principal contention is that each question presents two separate propositions and the combining of two or more different objectives in a single question is illegal on the ground the voter is not given a fair choice. See 29 C.J.S. Elections § 170, page 246.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit