Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York May 27, 1964, Claim No. 37708 (City of Albany v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-05-1964

Per Curiam.

The State appeals from a judgment of the Court of Claims in favor of respondent in the amount of $217,831.46, with interest, as compensation for certain lands appropriated for use in connection with the New York State Thruway.

Between 19'5i and 1954 the properties here involved were appropriated for the use of the Thruway. These properties fall into three categories: 14 parcels, totaling 16.784 acres, which were beds of streets; 12 parcels, totaling 61.413 acres, which had been used for water supply purposes, and 1 parcel of 50.506 *225acres also used for water supply purposes rendered inaccessible by reason of the other appropriations. Appellant urges that the properties involved were owned by the city in its governmental capacity and that therefore under the common-law rule, the taking by the State was not compensable (see, e.g., City of Schenectady v. State of New York, 6 Misc 2d 232, app. dsmd. 9 A D 2d 851 and cases cited therein). We have no difficulty in finding that both the land held for street purposes (e.g., People v. Grant, 306 N. Y. 258; Markey v. County of Queens, 154 N. Y. 675) and that used for water supply purposes (Brush v. Commissioner, 300 U. S. 352; Fire Ins. Co. v. Village of Keeseville, 148 N. Y. 46) were held in a governmental rather than a proprietary capacity. Respondent, however, argues that even if this be so the award should be sustained because the taking was by the Thruway Authority, which it is urged is not a taking by the State, or alternatively on the grounds that section 3 of the General Municipal Law, which changed the common-law rule to allow compensation to a municipality if the land to be taken is to be for a substantially different purpose from that for which it was held by the municipality, is applicable. We cannot agree with either contention.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.