New York Supreme Court January 22, 1964 (Streg, Inc. v. Herman)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-01-1964

Frank S. McCullough, J.

This is an article 78 proceeding brought by a landlord to review the determination of the State Rent Administrator for building-wide rent increases pursuant to subdivision 5 of section 33 of the State Rent and Eviction Regulations.

Under the State Emergency Housing Rent Control Law as implemented by subdivision 5 of section 33 of the State Rent and Eviction Regulations a landlord is entitled to obtain rent adjustments where needed, sufficient for it to realize a 6% net annual return on the appropriate index of its property’s value. The State Rent Administrator contends that a partial audit of the landlord’s books and records disclosed that the petitioner was already realizing more than the statutorily allowable return. *778Therefore, according to the State Bent Administrator, no adjustments were warranted and the application was denied.

The application was filed on December 28, 1961, using a test year from November 1, 1960 to October 31, 1961. The Local Bent Administrator apparently consumed 10 months to audit the application, and the order denying the petitioner’s application was not issued until just short of one full year after its submission.

The contention by the State Bent Administrator that no rent increases were warranted is primarily based on the fact that in the Summer of 1962 a number of voluntary increases in rent were obtained by the petitioner from certain tenants by lease agreements.

The principle now before the court is whether, in denying the application, the State Bent Administrator was entitled to take into account the increases in rent obtained by the petitioner after its application was filed and before the respondent’s partial audit was accomplished. The landlord contends that the State Bent Administrator violated a rule of its own established procedure, that of a so-called “ cut-off ” date, namely, the date of the filing of a rent increase application.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.