New York Supreme Court April 16, 1964 (Granet Construction Corp. v. Longo)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-04-1964

Samuel C. Coleman, J.

There has been a controversy of long standing between landlords and tenant. Landlords (two individuals) are the owners of two old-law tenement buildings and the tenant is in possession under a lease of the buildings which expires in 1968. The landlords have made unsuccessful efforts in the past to repossess the premises. The status of the litigation now is as follows: The tenant brought suit in this court to declare the lease in effect, and to enjoin the landlords from interfering with his possession and with the relations between him and the occupants of the several apartments. He brought summary proceedings in the Civil Court to evict one of the landlords who occupies an apartment in the buildings. In that action the landlords (the second individual landlord joining in the answer) counterclaimed, seeking possession of the premises. In the action brought in this court by the tenant, the landlords counterclaimed for damages for various breaches: nonpayment of rent, failure to make mortgage and other payments, failure to make repairs and to remove violations. Both actions were consolidated and are now before me.

*800The suit by the lessee to declare the lease in effect and the cause of action in the Civil Court by the landlords in summary proceedings are correlative, and will be considered together.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.