New York Supreme Court April 22, 1964 (OClassen v. City of New York)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-04-1964
Lester Holtzman, J.
Motion by the defendant to dismiss the complaint for insufficiency.
This is an action by a property owner for a judgment setting aside an in rem foreclosure proceeding, reinstating a tax lien and directing the defendant the City of New York to proceed by a tax lien s'ale, or, in the alternative, directing the defendant to pay to the plaintiff, after sale of the real estate by public auction, any and all sums received over and above the amount of the taxes, interest, penalties, costs, disbursements and fees incurred in the sale.
On April 19, 1963, a judgment of foreclosure was rendered in an in rem tax proceeding pursuant to chapter 17 of title D of the Administrative Code of the City of New York. (Foreclosure by action in rem.) The plaintiff herein defaulted in appearing in that proceeding. The taxes due were approximately $4,000. The value of the property was at least $18,000. Had the defendant proceeded by means of a judgment of fore*1041closure and sale, the plaintiff would have been entitled to the surplus moneys. Since defendant proceeded, however, by means of an in rem proceeding, the plaintiff is not entitled to the difference between the tax lien and the value of the property.
The complaint alleges, inter alla, that the defendant by arbitrarily proceeding under an in rem foreclosure instead of a tax lien sale, unjustly enriched itself and thereby has taken the plaintiff’s property without due process of law in violation of her constitutional rights. The constitutionality of an in rem foreclosure proceeding vis-a-vis a foreclosure and sale has been sustained by the Supreme Court of the United States. (Nelson v. New York City, 352 U. S. 103.) Accordingly, the complaint fails to state a cause of action for a judgment directing the defendant to proceed by a tax lien sale or directing the defendant to pay to the plaintiff the excess sums realized by it on the sale at auction of the property.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit