New York Supreme Court December 30, 1964 (People v. Quarles)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1964

Francis T. Murphy, Jr., J.

Defendant, indicted for robbery in the first degree, seeks pretrial discovery and inspection of transcribed statements made by him to law enforcement authorities after his arrest at a time when he was without the assistance of counsel, together with other related items of information.

The defendant’s affidavit avers, in substance, that he was arrested on June 7, 1964 at about 10:00 p.m. ; that he was questioned for approximately three and one-half hours at the 138th Street Precinct by a detective, and an Assistant District Attorney; that by reason of the lateness of the hour and the length of his interrogation he is unable to recall everything he said; that during the interrogation the detective took notes on a sheet of yellow paper; and an employee of the District Attorney recorded stenographically the questions asked by the Assistant District Attorney and the answers made by the defendant; that thereafter he was asked to sign the statement transcribed by the detective during the interrogation; that the statement so made was made without the benefit of counsel and without waiver of his right to counsel. The defendant refused to sign the statement as transcribed by the detective and it is this paper that is the subject of the discovery herein, as well as, the questions and answers recorded stenographically.

The basis of the New York law of pretrial discovery and inspection in a criminal case lies in the visionary pronouncement of Judge Cardozo in People ex rel. Lemon v. Supreme Court (245 N. Y. 24). After recognizing that “ (a)t common law, no right of inspection of documents before trial was conceded to the accused ” (6 Wigmore, Evidence [3rd ed., 1940], p. 475), the court declared (p.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.