Superior Court of Pennsylvania December 16, 1964, Appeal, No. 169 (Snider Unemployment Compensation Case)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-12-1964

Opinion by

Watkins, J.,

In this unemployment compensation case the Unemployment Compensation Board of Review reversed the referee and held the claimant to be an unemployed businessman and not an unemployed worker subject to the Act.

The claimant, Douglas E. Snider, was the president, manager and principal stockholder in Snider Chevrolet, Inc., a Pennsylvania corporation. This corporation operated a Chevrolet sales franchise. The record shows that the franchise was a successful one until a dispute developed between the claimant and General Motors Corporation. He clearly had a proprietary interest therein to the extent of 460 shares of nonvoting Class B stock and the Motors Holding Division of General Motors Corporation held the 440 shares of Class A voting stock. The Chevrolet franchise was a contract between General Motors and the claimant. General Motors was not his employer. He was employed by the Snider Corporation at a salary of $1400 per month with options to purchase voting shares through a dealer investment plan. As profits were made by the Snider corporation the claimant was buying Class A stock and had, at the time of his dismissal, purchased 60 shares of such stock but they would not become voting shares until the entire ownership came to the Snider corporation. In order to obtain the franchise the claimant had agreed to invest forty thousand dollars of his own money in the business. This was to be unencumbered funds but in violation of the agreement the claimant borrowed the money that was invested and when this was discov*540ered by General Motors the franchise was cancelled. The record shows that the franchise was successfully operated by Snider corporation until this dispute developed. The record also shows that the corporation was in a position to either secure another franchise or liquidate and the directors of the corporation decided to liquidate. There is no question but that the loss of the franchise caused the liquidation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.