Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court January 30, 1964 (Quincy Trust Co. v. Town of Pembroke)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-01-1964
Spiegel, J.
This is an action of contract brought by an assignee to recover damages for an alleged failure by the defendant to pay part of an assigned debt. The case was tried in the Superior Court on a statement of agreed facts, which included a contract incorporated by reference. The judge ordered judgment for the defendant from which the plaintiff appealed.
*731In 1958 the defendant entered into a written contract with National Associates, Inc. (National). Under its terms, National was to make a revaluation of the defendant’s taxable property, was to he present at hearings of the defendant’s board of assessors to defend values and assist in the settlement of complaints, and was to provide the defendant with record cards containing essential information on the property assessed. On November 14,1958, the defendant issued a letter to the plaintiff consenting to a proposed “assignment of $9,000 from the National Associates, Inc. to the Quincy Trust Company of their interests in the above-mentioned contract.”1 On November 26, 1958, National assigned to the plaintiff its interest in the unpaid balance. In March, 1959, the defendant paid the plaintiff the sum of $4,500 but made no subsequent payment. In November, 1959, National was adjudicated a bankrupt, and in January, 1960, the defendant voluntarily paid to National’s trustee in bankruptcy the sum of $3,000 to secure possession of the record cards.
At the time of the assignment, National had performed all services owed to the defendant under the contract except that it had not participated in the complaint and adjustment hearings and had not delivered the record cards. It appears that National never participated in the hearings. The defendant’s assessors never issued a certification that the contract had been fulfilled, unless the letter of November 14, 1958, is deemed to be such a certificate.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit