Supreme Court of Florida December 21, 1964, No. 32943 (State ex rel. Callahan v. Michell)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-12-1964

BARNS, PAUL D., Justice (Ret.)

This matter is before this Court upon a petition for certiorari to review the decision in the appeal to the District Court of Appeal, Second District, from a final judgment in habeas corpus as reported in Michell, as Sheriff v. State ex rel. Callahan, Jr., Fla. App.1963, 154 So.2d 701. We find the ground of the petition without merit and deny it.

The ground of petition for certiorari is as follows:

“The respondent Sheriff appealed to the District Court, Second District, from the habeas corpus proceedings without first obtaining the consent of the Judge of the Circuit Court who issued the Order appealed from — or any Judge of the said Fifteenth Judicial Circuit or any Appellant Court of Justices as required by § 79.11, Florida Statutes Annotated.”

It appears that this ground was raised by the petitioner in the case appealed for the first time in his Petition for Rehearing as follows:

“That appellant failed to invoke the jurisdiction of the Court (of Appeal) pursuant to 79.11, F.S.A. in that the Circuit Court did not grant authority for the Appeal.”

The petition for rehearing was merely denied and petitioner now seeks certiorari *291review by reason of a sub silentio conflict “on the same point of law”, Section 4(2), Article V, of the Constitution, F.S.A., between the denial and the cases of State v. Quigg, 17 So.2d 698; Brister v. Brister, 29 So.2d 699; and Griffith v. State ex rel. Crownover, Fla.App.1963, 152 So.2d 818.

Section 79.11, F.S.A., is a remanent of the comprehensive habeas corpus procedure act of 1879, Chapter 3129, Laws of Florida, Section 10 of which act provided that:

“The judge hearing the cause, shall grant to any party aggrieved by the judgment a writ of error returnable to the next term of the supreme court, * He *»

Section 79.11, F.S.A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.