Supreme Court of Colorado May 4, 1964, No. 20,635 (Oswald v. Dawn)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-05-1964

Opinion by

Mr. Justice Moore.

We will refer to plaintiffs in error as plaintiffs or by name, and to defendants in error as defendants or by name.

A detailed statement of the facts giving rise to this controversy will be found in the opinion of this court in Oswald v. Dawn, et al., 143 Colo. 487, 354 P. (2d) 505. In that opinion the case was remanded to the trial court for further proceedings. Following that remand the trial court retried the case and arrived at the same conclusion that had been reached on the first trial.

Plaintiffs are heirs-at-law of one George Oswald, deceased, who during his lifetime was a partner of the defendant Clyde S. Dawn. A number of separate business enterprises had been operated by said partners. A bank account was maintained by the partners under the name Dawn-Oswald Real Estate Company, and this litigation stems from certain withdrawals made by Dawn from that account.

Plaintiffs and defendants agreed that one Richard Azar, a Certified Public Accountant, should conduct an audit of the partnership books, records and accounts, and determine a balance. While the plaintiff Elizabeth Oswald did not testify that the parties were to be bound by this audit, the evidence supporting that conclusion was strong and the findings of the trial court clearly indicated that the audit was to be conclusive upon the parties.

As pointed out in the former opinion, the major item of controversy was the allowance by Azar of the sum of *574approximately $20,000.00 as a credit to Dawn, which was paid to him from the account of Dawn-Oswald Real Estate Company for services actually rendered in connection with the operation of the Rugby Coal Company another partnership enterprise. The effect of our former opinion was that the allowance of this credit was made on an inadequate and insufficient showing in the evidence, and the trial court was directed to determine by competent evidence whether the defendant Dawn was “entitled to credit for salary and expenses.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.