Mississippi Supreme Court October 5, 1964, No. 43074 (Boyd v. Donald)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-10-1964

Gillespie, J.

This appeal by the defendant below from judgment awarding plaintiff damages in an automobile collision raises several questions, the principal one being whether a written accident report made by an investigating officer, which is inconsistent with the officer’s testimony at trial, is admissible for purposes of impeachment.

Mrs. Linda Donald filed suit against the administrator of the estate of John H. Oliphant for the wrongful death of plaintiff’s husband, Jerrel Donald. The accident occurred a mile south of Carthage on a paved highway. Oliphant was driving alone in a pickup truck, going south. Jerrel Donald was driving an automobile north with his wife and baby as passengers. Oliphant, Jerrel Donald and the baby were killed in the collision. It was alleged by the plaintiff that Oliphant was drunk and drove his truck across the center line of the highway into his left lane so as to collide headon with the Donald automobile when the Donald automobile was being driven on its proper side of the highway. Several witnesses testified that Oliphant had been drinking prior to the accident. Two eye witnesses testified that Oliphant drove his vehicle across the center line directly into the path of the Donald vehicle. The only testimony favorable to the defendant was the fact that the front ends of the two vehicles came to rest on the west side of the center line of the highway and most of the debris was on that side of the highway. This was explained by the eye witnesses who testified that when the two vehicles collided, the front ends rose into the air and fell across the center line and came to rest with the front ends in the west lane of the highway. The proof was ample to sustain the charges of negligence. In our view the evidence was overwhelming in favor of the plaintiff.

Appellant’s first assignment of error complains of the action of the trial court in overruling a motion *623for a continuance.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.