Supreme Court of Puerto Rico November 4, 1964, Nos. 445, 446 (Atiles Moréu ex rel. Castro del Valle v. San Juan Trading Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-11-1964

Mr. Justice Dávila

delivered the opinion of the Court.

Susano Castro del Valle worked for an independent freight carrier duly insured with the State Insurance Fund. He was struck by some bales of jute sacks while performing the duties of his occupation. He suffered serious injuries. He was compensated by the Fund.

The Manager of the State Insurance Fund, subrogating himself in the rights of the laborer, filed in the Superior Court, San Juan Part, the civil action which we now consider. He joined as defendants the San Juan Trading Co., Inc., Alcoa Steamship Co., owner of the pier and warehouse where the accident occurred, and James Nourse, Ltd., a British shipping company owner of the motor ship “Shah-zada” aboard which the cargo of bales in question arrived in San Juan. He based his claim on the alleged negligence of San Juan Trading Co. and/or James Nourse, Ltd., whose agents and/or employees formed the stack from which the bales broke loose, “such stack having been improperly and negligently made and reinforced with wooden beams by defendants, their agents and/or employees,” causing the dis-lodgment which injured appellant.

In their answers defendants denied the averments of negligence and damages. James Nourse, Ltd. and San Juan Trading Co., Inc., filed claims against coparties, the former *157holding the San Juan Trading Co., Inc., and Alcoa Steamship Co. liable for the damages caused, and the latter alleging that any intervention and participation in the stack had been in its capacity of agent for James Nourse and within the limits of the agency without negligence, wherefore the liability was assignable to Nourse, the principal.

The hearing of the case having been held on the merits, by stipulation of the parties the claims against Alcoa Steamship Co. were dismissed. At the close of the evidence the trial court dismissed the complaint as to James Nourse, Ltd., dismissed the claim against coparties, and rendered judgment ordering the San Juan Trading Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.