Supreme Court of Louisiana December 14, 1964, No. 47299 (State v. Watson)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-12-1964

lead-opinion

HAMITER, Justice.

The defendant, Roosevelt Watson, is appealing from a conviction and a sentence to life imprisonment for the crime of aggravated rape, and he presents for our consideration twelve perfected hills of exceptions, any one of which (if meritorious) would entitle him at the most to a new trial inasmuch as each addresses itself to an issue that arose during the course of the trial.

But the accused failed to move for a new trial in the district court. And when this appeal was taken, as well as when the transcript was lodged here (May 22, 1964), the timely making of such a motion was a prerequisite in view of LRS 15 :559 which then stated: “No new trial can he granted on appeal unless a motion for same has been made and refused in the lower court * * *.” See State v. Richardson, 220 La. 338, 56 So.2d 568, State v. Ramsey, 242 La. 1089, 141 So.2d 375, and State v. Schellinger, 243 La. 231, 142 So.2d 406.

When the appeal chine on for a hearing the. state relied on LRS 15:559 and'the' above cited cases to support its argument that we could not give consideration to the perfected hills. Defense counsel, on the other hand, urged that “in the interest of justice” we should consider them, despite the quoted statutory provision and the mentioned holdings, he relying on two earlier decisions which had been superceded by the later cases.

Following oral argument and submission of the case, however, our research revealed that, while this appeal was pending, LRS 15 :559 was repealed in its entirety by Act No. 516 of 1964 — a statute that had not been discussed or even mentioned previously by either the state’s attorney or defense counsel. Thereupon, counsel for both parties were instructed to file supplemental briefs on the issue respecting the effect of the repealing statute on this cause. However, such documents, which were submitted as directed, have furnished little assistance to us.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.