Oregon Supreme Court May 12, 1965 (State v. Clifton)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-05-1965

O’CONNELL, J.

Defendant appeals from a judgment of conviction of the crime of assault while being armed with a dangerous weapon. It is contended that defendant’s constitutional rights to counsel and to remain silent were violated.

Defendant made incriminating statements during interrogation by police officers. Defendant was not informed of his constitutional rights before the interrogation. When the police officers testified no objection was made to their testimony relating to the incriminating statements. The state concedes that if objection had been made there would be reversible error. The only question on appeal is whether defendant’s failure to object constitutes a waiver of his constitutional rights to counsel and to remain silent.

At the time of the trial

Escobedo v. Illinois,

378 US 478, 84 S Ct 1758, 12 L Ed2d 977 (1964) had not been decided. It is probable that if it had been decided at the time of defendant’s trial appropriate objections would have been made. Under these circumstances we believe that the failure to object to the testimony of the police officers did not constitute a waiver of defendant’s constitutional rights.

We express no opinion as to whether a failure to object would constitute a waiver in a case tried after

Escobedo v. Illinois,

supra.

The fact that the present case was tried prior to the decision in

Escobedo v. Illinois,

supra, does not present a question of the retroactive effect of the

*380

Escobedo

case because it is our view that a newly-pronounced principle of constitutional law is operative with respect to all cases being tried or upon direct appeal in the courts of this state at the time of the pronouncement. See

People v. Stewart,

43 Cal Rptr 201, 400 P2d 97 (1965). It is not necessary to decide whether the principle in

Escobedo

is to be given effect in cases where a judgment of conviction together with final disposition on direct appeal preceded the decision in

Escobedo.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.