Supreme Court of North Carolina June 18, 1965, 661 (State v. Merritt)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-06-1965

*719

Shabp, J.

The first question presented by this appeal is: Did the judge presiding over a session of the Superior Court of Guilford County have authority to hear and pass upon a petition filed in Guilford County under G.S. 15-217

et seq.

to review the constitutionality of the prisoner’s convictions in any county other than Guilford?

The North Carolina Post-Conviction Hearing Act (G.S. 15-217 through 15-222) originated as Sess. Laws of 1951, ch. 1083. Codified as Gen. Stats, ch. 15, art. XXII, it is entitled “Review of the Constitutionality of Criminal Trials.” Like the Illinois act on which it was modeled,

Miller v. State,

237 N.C. 29, 74 S.E. 2d 513 (see

People v. Dale,

406 Ill. 238, 92 N.E. 2d 761, for the Illinois act), the Act was passed “to replace the ancient and little known or understood writ of error

coram nobis,”

29 N.C.L. Rev. 390, 391, insofar as the review of the constitutionality of criminal trials is concerned. The remedy afforded by the Act “closely resembles that available under the common-law writ.”

People v. Bernatowicz,

413 Ill. 181, 184, 108 N.E. 2d 479, 481,

cert. den.

345 U.S. 928, 73 S. Ct. 788, 97 L. Ed. 1358. The writ of error

coram nobis

“is brought for an alleged error of fact, not appearing upon the record, and

lies to the same court,

in order that it may correct the error, which it is presumed would not have been committed had the fact in the first instance been brought to its notice.” Battle, J., in

Roughton v. Brown,

53 N.C. 393, 394. (Italics ours.) This explanation has been widely adopted,

Ernst v. State,

179 Wis. 646, 192 N.W. 65, 30 A.L.R. 681; 18 Am. Jur. 2d, Coram Nobis and Allied Statutory Remedies § 2 (1965); 5 Wharton, Criminal Law and Procedure § 2252 (Anderson’s Ed. 1957). “Error in fact,” however, does not mean that guilt or innocence is an issue in

coram nobis

proceedings. “(I)t is not the purpose of the writ to review evidence presented at the trial.” 18 Am. Jur.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.