Appellate Court of Illinois September 24, 1965, Gen. 50,129 (People v. McDonald)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-09-1965

MR. JUSTICE ENGLISH

delivered the opinion of the court.

In a bench trial defendant was convicted of murder and on November 17, 1961 he was sentenced to a term of twenty years.

1

On writ of error, review was sought in the Supreme Court which has transferred the case to this court.

The facts are essentially undisputed, and the sole point raised by defendant is that he should have been found guilty of voluntary manslaughter only.

In 1961 defendant was 47 years old. He had been living with Babe Butler for some 25 years. He testified that he loved her. She was 4'9" tall and was 84 years old.

Shortly after midnight on August 12, 1961 defendant and three coworkers at the steel plant finished work for the day. On the way home in a car they consumed some whiskey and beer. Defendant invited the others to indulge in more of the same at his apartment and they accepted. "When they arrived there at about 12:40 a. m. there were no lights on in the apartment. Upon turning on the light, defendant saw Babe in bed and one Fat standing at the foot of the bed. Both were fully clothed. Defendant was acquainted with Fat but did not know him by any other name.

Defendant proceeded to get out a half-pint bottle of whiskey. He then told his friends to go into the breakfast room where they resumed their drinking. Fat, exhibiting either a high degree of savoir faire or, as argued by defendant, extreme effrontery, asked defendant for a cigarette. Being told by defendant that he didn’t have any, Fat departed from the premises. As he was leaving, Miss Butler said to him, “Stop in, come back.”

The supply of whiskey was exhausted by 1:05 a. m. so defendant and friends walked to a nearby tavern where they stayed until it closed at 2:00 a.ra. They then went to a “chicken shack” and ate some fish and chips. From there they walked back to defendant’s apartment shortly before 4:00 a. m. The three friends got in their car and left.

Defendant saw a light on his porch.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.