Supreme Court of Minnesota July 23, 1965, 39654 (Johnson v. R. E. Tapley, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-07-1965
*20
Otis, Justice.
Plaintiffs have recovered damages against defendants for injuries sustained by Mrs. Johnson when she fell while leaving defendants’ store in the village of Wadena. Defendants appeal from the judgment.
On June 16, 1962, shortly before noon, Mrs. Johnson entered defendants’ store and bought one or two small items in the period of approximately one-half hour. She departed by the same door she had used to enter, carrying a handbag and one package containing her purchases. As she reached the sidewalk, she missed a 514 -inch step and fell from a cement slab constructed in such a manner that its surface extended 2 feet from one of the double doors and 3 feet from the other, tapering in a V shape from the doorway in either direction to the end of the display windows facing the sidewalk. The entrance is depicted in the accompanying cut.
There are two issues for consideration, first, whether the evidence sustains plaintiffs’ theory of where the accident occurred; and second, whether the display windows at the entrance constituted a distraction which excused Mrs. Johnson’s failure to see the step from which she fell.
*21
The theory advanced by plaintiffs and adopted by the trial court would permit the jury to find Mrs. Johnson was not injured while departing directly through the door to the sidewalk, but that she walked along the elevated slab of cement, which tapered to the corner of the window, while distracted by the display facing the street. In denying the defendants’ motion for a directed verdict, the trial court observed that the “illegitimate construction existing in front of the doors, plus the display windows placed there by defendants” combined to create a jury question as to defendants’ negligence.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit