Court of Appeals of Texas April 20, 1965, No. 7624 (United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co. v. Turner)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-04-1965
CHADICK, Chief Justice.
This is a Workmen’s Compensation Law case. Compensation was awarded a workman plaintiff by the judgment of the trial court and the judgment is affirmed.
Conduct prejudicial to the appellant, ascribed to certain jurors and the jury as a whole, said to have occurred in the course of jury deliberations, is the error relied upon for reversal. When an issue of fact is presented by the evidence offered to prove jury misconduct, and the issue is decided by the trial judge, this court is bound by the trial court’s finding. State v. Wair, 163 Tex. 69, 351 S.W.2d 878 (1961); Appellate Procedure in Texas, Sec. 17.16 “Jury Misconduct”. All parties grant that this rule should be applied when pertinent.
The compensation carrier at the hearing on its motion for new trial tendered the testimony of two jurors. From this course it was shown that as the jury assembled for deliberation an unidentified juror remarked in substantially this language: “Well, let’s give this man all that he asks for. Let’s just find out how to do it.” Subsequently another juror unnamed by the witnesses expressed his opinion that a per*304son could not obtain anything from a compensation insurer unless a law suit was brought. Still another juror, name not stated, was heard to avow that he knew of other persons having similar hurts that were permanently incapacitated. By way of opposition, denial and explanation, the testimony of the jury foreman and three other jurors was offered by counsel for the workman. In substance they testified either that they did not hear or did not recall any of these utterances. These jurors agreed that the remarks and conversations under investigation could have occurred without their knowledge, as several different conversations were frequently in progress at the same time with much overlapping of speech and expressions. Also, that their attention could have been diverted from such talk in some other manner.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit