Supreme Court of North Carolina September 22, 1965 (Dixon v. Bank of Washington)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-09-1965
Bobbitt, J.
The only exceptions brought forward in appellant's brief challenge the sufficiency of plaintiff’s allegations and evidence to support a recovery for services rendered by plaintiff to David Clark more than three years prior to his death.
Decision requires that plaintiff’s allegations and evidence be considered in relation to the well-established legal principles stated below.
“When services are performed by one person for another under an agreement or mutual understanding (fairly to be inferred from their *324conduct, declarations and attendant circumstances) that compensation therefor is to be provided in the will of the person receiving the benefit of such services, and the latter dies intestate or fails to make such provision, a cause of action accrues in favor of the person rendering the services.” Stewart v. Wyrick, 228 N.C. 429, 431, 45 S.E. 2d 764, and cases cited; Speights v. Carraway, 247 N.C. 220, 222, 100 S.E. 2d 339.
“The remedy of the promisee who has rendered personal services in consideration of an oral contract to devise real estate void under the statute of frauds is an action on implied assumpsit or quantum meruit for the value of the services rendered.” Pickelsimer v. Pickelsimer, 257 N.C. 696, 699, 127 S.E. 2d 557, and cases cited.
“When personal services are rendered with the understanding that compensation is to be made in the will of the recipient, payment therefor does not become due until death, and the statutes of limitation do not begin to run until that time.” Stewart v. Wyrick, supra, p. 432; Doub v. Hauser, 256 N.C. 331, 337, 123 S.E. 2d 821.
While there are contradictions in the evidence as to their extent and value, there is plenary evidence plaintiff rendered personal services to David Clark, including washing, ironing, cooking and nursing, from 1955 until his death, intestate, on May 30, 1963, at the age of 79. Plaintiff alleged the services she rendered were reasonably worth a total of $14,820.00 based on $30.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit