Supreme Court of Arkansas March 22, 1965, 5-3504 (Ark. State Highway Comm. v. Lay)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-03-1965
Paul Ward, Associate Justice.
This is an eminent domain action brought by the Arkansas Highway Commission (hereafter referred to as appellant) to acquire approximately 1.2 acres of land belonging to Wallace Lay, who is now incompetent, and who will hereafter be referred to as appellee. The land, which was at the junction of highways 19 and 65, is located in Van Burén County about a mile from Clinton.
Other parties mentioned as defendants in the suit, but who have no particular interest in this appeal, are a Mr. Dempsey, guardian of appellee, and a Mr. Keeling who held (at the time this action was begun) a 19 month lease on appellee’s property for which he was paying $50 per month.
Based on a jury verdict the trial court rendered judgment vesting title to the property in appellant, and giving appellee judgment in the amount of $16,975. The only points raised by appellant on appeal are: One. The trial court erred in not striking the testimony of two witnesses for appellee; and Two. The trial court erred (a) in refusing to give appellant’s requested Instruction No. 1, and (b) in giving its own Instruction No. 5. The pertinent testimony relative to the points raised will be summarized as each point is hereafter discussed.
One. (a) Appellee’s first witness who testified as to the value of the condemned land was Ray Wheeler. His pertinent testimony, in substance, was: I am 41 years old; have been a real estate broker for 19 years — 15 years having been spent in Yan Burén County; I have completed approximately 1300 real estate transactions; and am acquainted with real estate values in this county; I am familiar with the condemned land and the improvements thereon. In my opinion its highest and best use is for commercial, tourist, and resort property, and I value it at $24,250. During his testimony the witness referred to the fact that there was an existing lease on the property and, in effect, his testimony was not clear as to the length or value of the lease.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit