United States Court of Claims January 22, 1965, No. 71-63 (Hughes Transportation, Inc. v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-01-1965
Durfee, Judge,
delivered the opinion of the court:
This claim for refund by plaintiff concerns the applicable charges for shipments of ammunition by plaintiff for defendant. During the month of June 1951, plaintiff motor carrier transported 15 shipments of ammunition on 15 Government bills of lading from Fort Estill, Kentucky to Milan, Tennessee. The initial billing by plaintiff and payment by defendant for these shipments was pursuant to a special rate specified for the Government by plaintiff under a Section 22 Quotation No. 34, effective June 22, 1951, the day before the first transportation of these 15 shipments. A Section 22 Quotation is a contract and special tariff under 49 TJ.S.C. § 22, giving the United States a different, preferential rate from that available to the public. Quotation No. 34 was applicable on “Ammunition and Explosives.” As to the rate and minimum weight per shipment, Quotation No. 34 required:
INTERSTATE RATES
Kates to apply will be 65% of the current first (1st) class motor carrier rates published in tariffs to which Hughes Transportation, Inc. is a party subject to 65% of the current rail first (1st) class rates as maximum.
* ❖ * * ❖
MINIMUM WEIGHT
Volume minimum weight of 50,000 pounds subject to truckload minimum of 20,000 pounds when quantity tendered for shipment at any one time is less than 50,000 pounds in weight.
The resulting rate under Quotation No. 34 was $1.54 per hundred pounds, subject to the minimum weight provisions. Previously plaintiff’s applicable tariff rate was $1.93 per *65hundred pounds subject to a minimum weight of 20,000 pounds. Plaintiff’s purpose in tendering Quotation No. 34 to the Government was to meet railroad competition; the quotation specified that its specified rate of 65 percent of the first class motor carrier rate was “subject to 65% of the current rail -first class rates as maximum.” [Emphasis supplied.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit