District Court, S.D. New York January 27, 1965, Serial No. 5133-172930 (United States v. $1,845.00 in United States Currency)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-01-1965
BONSAL, District Judge.
The Government has instituted a libel against $1,845.00 in United States currency and one 1963 Dodge Coupe. Claimant, Ralph Conti, has filed a claim seeking the return of the property, asserting that this property was seized from him illegally on January 22,1964. The Government served a notice on the claimant to take his deposition on January 7, 1964 (presumably 1965 was intended). In response, claimant has moved for an order directing that his deposition shall not be taken, or, if taken, shall be taken under the protection of Admiralty Rule 30. The Government opposes claimant’s motion and has moved for a stay of all further *999proceedings in the libel action pending the completion of contemplated criminal proceedings against the claimant.
It appears that the claimant was arrested under a complaint charging him with gambling, and that his car and the currency were seized pursuant to a warrant at or about the time of his arrest. The criminal complaint is still pending.
In this libel proceeding claimant filed a note of issue on December 17,1964, and on December 21 the Government served its notice to take claimant’s deposition on January 7, 1964 (presumably 1965 was intended). It also appears that the Government objected to claimant’s note of issue on the ground that claimant, by invoking his rights under the Fifth Amendment and by claiming the protection of Admiralty Rule 30, was seeking to frustrate the Government’s right to pre-trial discovery in the libel action. Claimant counters by asserting that the Government has not as yet pressed the criminal complaint and may not do so, and that the criminal complaint is merely a pretext to deny him his day in court in the libel proceeding and the return of his money and the automobile.
The Court finds nothing in Admiralty Rule 30 which denies the Government the right to take the deposition of the claimant.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit