District Court, S.D. New York May 12, 1965 (Bilkay Holding Corp. v. City of New York)

WEINFELD, District Judge.

After observing and appraising the credibility of the witnesses who participated in or observed the events which led to the capsizing of the nonpropelled deck scow Florence R and the loss of her cargo, I have concluded that the occurrence was due to the joint fault of her towing tug, the James F.