Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit January 18, 1965, 15514_1 (The Associated Press v. Taft-Ingalls Corporation, Formerly Known as the Cincinnati Times-Star Company)

O’SULLIVAN, Circuit Judge

(dissenting) .

I regret my inability to agree with the learned, exhaustive and painstaking opinion of my brothers. The critical holding of such opinion is that, as a matter of fact, the variety of news furnished over AP’s Ohio wire constitutes a commodity distinct and separate from the news furnished over its other wire services and that AP must, for a separate price and