Supreme Court of North Carolina January 14, 1966, 767 (University Motors, Inc. v. Durham Coca-Cola Bottling Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-01-1966

Bobbitt, J.

Plaintiff’s appeal presents these questions: (1) Did the court err in denying plaintiff’s motion to nonsuit corporate defendant’s counterclaim? (2) Did the court err in denying plaintiff’s motion to strike defendants’ first further answer and defense?

*255

(3) Did the court err in denying plaintiff’s motion to strike the testimony quoted in our preliminary statement relating to payments made to plaintiff by its collision insurance carrier?

There is ample evidence that the collision and resulting damage were proximately caused by Goodwin’s negligence. Plaintiff contends that defendants’ evidence establishes

as a matter of law

that Moss was contributorily negligent. With reference to the counterclaim, the corporate defendant’s status is that of a plaintiff. Hence, in passing upon whether the court should have nonsuited the counterclaim, the evidence must be considered in the light most favorable to the corporate defendant. Evidence favorable to plaintiff must be disregarded.

Gillikin v. Mason,

256 N.C. 533, 124 S.E. 2d 541;

Robinette v. Wike,

265 N.C. 551, 144 S.E. 2d 594.

While the evidence was in sharp conflict, there was evidence sufficient to permit the jury to make the factual findings narrated below.

Goodwin approached and entered the intersection, traveling in the east lane of Duke, when the signal light facing him was red. The collision occurred in the east lane of Duke, .approximately 10 feet north of the south curb line of Trinity and 20-25 feet east of the west curb of Duke. The front of the Chrysler collided with the right side of the Coca-Cola truck “right behind the cab.” The Chrysler made skid marks 36 feet long. They began 26 feet south of the south curb of Trinity.

Physical conditions at the southwest corner of said intersection obstructed to an undefined extent Goodwin’s view of eastbound traffic on Trinity and Moss’ view of northbound traffic on Duke.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.