Utah Supreme Court December 9, 1966, 10583 (HOWE RENTS CORPORATION v. Worthen)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-12-1966
combined-opinion
18 Utah 2d 263 (1966) 420 P.2d 848 HOWE RENTS CORPORATION, PLAINTIFF AND RESPONDENT, v. JOHN WORTHEN, DBA EXOTIC SWIMMING POOL COMPANY, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT. No. 10583. Supreme Court of Utah. December 9, 1966. K. Samuel King, Salt Lake City, for appellant. R. William Bradford, Jr., and John M. Bradley, Salt Lake City, for Howe Rents Corp. CALLISTER, Justice. This is an action based on a written contract of bailment for damage done to plaintiff's equipment while in the possession of the bailee, defendant. Plaintiff is in the business of renting equipment to the public. Defendant, a swimming pool contractor, rented a cement mixer from plaintiff on August 4, 1962. Without assistance from defendant, plaintiff attached the mixer to defendant's two-ton truck by means of a chain and ball hitch. Subsequently, while the defendant was towing the mixer, it came loose and overturned, causing damage to it. The case was tried before the court, and judgment was awarded to plaintiff after the court had considered the pleadings, the contract, and the stipulation of counsel as to the facts. The trial court ruled that the bailor was entitled to recover from the bailee for the damage to the bailed chattel under the terms of the bailment contract. This, in spite of the fact that the bailor's negligence and that it was the proximate cause of the damage had been placed in issue by defendant's answer and the pre-trial order. In other words, the negligence of the bailor, if any, would not constitute a defense to the bailor's claim for damages under the terms of the agreement. The sole issue of this case is whether the provisions of this bailment contract can be so interpreted as to render the bailee liable for damages caused by the negligent acts of the bailor; so that the bailee's allegations of the bailor's negligence do not constitute a defense in this action.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit