District Court, N.D. Illinois February 17, 1966, 65 C 1862 (Majerus v. Coyle)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-02-1966
WILL, District Judge.
Plaintiff, administrator of the estate of Walter T. Graf, brings this action to recover $3,542.66, allegedly erroneously assessed by defendant District Director of Internal Revenue in auditing the 1962 income tax return of the decedent’s estate. Included in the return was the report of the redemption of 370 shares of capital stock of Graf Fur Company, Inc. Plaintiff treated the entire net profit from the redemption as a capital gain pursuant to § 303 of the Internal Revenue Code, 26 U.S.C. § 303.
Under that section, stock redemptions otherwise taxable as ordinary income may be taxed at capital gains rates to the extent that the redemption is required to obtain funds to pay estate, inheritance and similar taxes, funeral expenses and those administration expenses which are allowed as deductions when computing the federal estate tax under § 2053 of the Code. In computing the amount of profit
from
the stock redemption subject to capital gains treatment, plaintiff included $15,750, the statutory widow’s award paid to decedent’s widow, as an administration expense of the estate. Inclusion of this sum was disallowed by the Director on the ground that a widow’s award does not qualify as an administration expense under § 2053 and the profit to the extent of $15,750 was therefore taxable as ordinary income. This action is brought to determine the legality of the Director’s determination.
Plaintiff’s claim is based on two contentions. First, he points out that, under Illinois law, the widow’s award must be
*215
paid prior to the payment of taxes and other debts and, that therefore he would have been unable to pay taxes and other claims had he not first used some of the proceeds of the stock redemption to pay the widow’s award. Second, plaintiff asserts that no definition of “administration expenses” is found in § 2053, federal tax regulations or judicial decisions and and that state law should therefore govern.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit