Texas Supreme Court November 2, 1966, A-11267 (Stacks v. East Dallas Clinic)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-11-1966

combined-opinion

409 S.W.2d 842 (1966) Marvin G. STACKS, Petitioner, v. EAST DALLAS CLINIC et al., Respondents. No. A-11267. Supreme Court of Texas. November 2, 1966. Rehearing Denied January 18, 1967. *843 Fritz, Vinson & Turley, Dallas, for petitioner. Abney & Burleson, Ernest Conner, Dallas, for respondents. GREENHILL, Justice. This is an action in which Marvin G. Stacks seeks to recover double the amount of usurious interest paid by him to the defendants, East Dallas Clinic, C. N. Duncan, M.D., R. D. Mahon, M.D., Walter H. Patton, M.D., William T. Green, M.D., and East Dallas Hospital, Inc., under article 5073.[1] The determination of the case necessarily requires a construction of that statute. Article 1728 § 3. Trial was to a jury in county court where the court instructed a verdict in Stack's favor. Judgment was entered for plaintiff in the amount of $305.10. The Court of Civil Appeals sitting at Tyler reversed and remanded. 397 S.W. 2d 558. The question presented for decision here is whether the defendants received a benefit from the usurious interest paid to them by Stacks and which they in turn paid to a third person. We hold they did not. The suit was instituted by Stacks against East Dallas Clinic, a partnership of physicians above named and East Dallas Hospital, Inc., a corporation that owns the hospital used by these physicians. Since these two organizations operated in effect as one entity, they will be hereinafter referred to as the Clinic. Stack's wife had an operation at the East Dallas Hospital in February of 1961, and her physician was from the East Dallas Clinic. The total bill was $652.90. Stacks signed two notes payable to the Republic National Bank, one for $325.00, due the Clinic for the doctor's bill, and the other for $327.90, due the Hospital for hospital charges. Benson, the Clinic's credit manager, told Stacks that the monthly payments on the two notes would be $54.41 for twelve months, and these were to be deposited with the bank.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.