Supreme Court of Arkansas April 25, 1966, 5-3851 (Ark. State Highway Commission v. Parks)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-04-1966
combined-opinion
401 S.W.2d 732 (1966) ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION, Appellant, v. Earl PARKS et al., Appellees. No. 5-3851. Supreme Court of Arkansas. April 25, 1966. *733 George Green and Don Langston, Little Rock, for appellant. Howell, Price & Worsham, Little Rock, Clark, Clark & Clark, Conway, for appellees. GEORGE ROSE SMITH, Justice. This is an eminent domain proceeding in which the Highway Commission is taking, for a highway right-of-way, 10.89 acres of a 41-acre tract and 8.09 acres of an 84-acre tract. The jury awarded the owners $8,000 for one taking and $6,000 for the other. The verdicts were somewhat smaller than the landowners' claims but more than double the amounts deposited in court by the Commission as the estimated value of the lands being acquired. For reversal the appellant insists that it was prejudiced by the introduction of incompetent evidence. Morris High, an expert witness, on direct examination gave his opinion about the value of the lands. On cross examination counsel for the condemnor elicited from the witness an admission that in reaching his conclusion he had considered the number and value of the lots that could be created if the tracts were platted and dedicated as residential subdivisions (which had not been done). Inasmuch as that method of evaluation is not one that may properly be submitted to the jury, it is now contended that the court should have sustained counsel's motion to strike the witness's testimony. This is the argument we rejected in Arkansas State Highway Commn. v. Russell, 240 Ark. 21, 398 S.W.2d 201 (1966), in an opinion handed down after the trial of the case at bar. We need not repeat our discussion. The Commission's second point is that the court erred in permitting the landowners to introduce a plat of Earl's Lakeside Subdivision. That subdivision is an undeveloped tract lying near the appellees' property.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit