Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit August 25, 1966, 21760 (Navigazione Alta Italia v. Keystone Shipping Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-08-1966

JONES, Circuit Judge:

About 11:30 o’clock during the night of February 15, 1961, the freighter Monfiore, owned by the appellant, Navigazione Alta Italia, and the tanker Spirit of Liberty, owned by the appellee, Keystone Shipping Company, collided in the Houston Ship Channel. The libel of the appellee, claiming damage of $60,000 to the Spirit of Liberty, was met by a cross-libel of the appellant seeking an award of $180,000 for damage to the Monfiore, with each party asserting that the collision resulted from the sole fault of the other. During a lengthy trial many witnesses testified and a number of exhibits were received in evidence. At the conclusion of the trial the court announced that the decision would be against the Monfiore and its owner, the appellant, and in favor of the owner of the Spirit of Liberty, the appellee. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were made as submitted by the counsel for the appellee. An interlocutory decree was entered determining that the collision was caused by the sole fault of the Monfiore. Its owner has appealed.

The appellee takes the position that the only question is whether or not the findings of the district court are clearly erroneous and, submitting that each finding is based upon overwhelming evidence, says that there should be an affirmance of the district court’s judgment under the principle of McAllister v. United States, 348 U.S. 19, 75 S.Ct. 6, 99 L.Ed. 20. The appellant, on the other hand, says that the district court misapplied the major-minor fault rule and erred in failing to determine that the Spirit of Liberty was guilty of statutory fault requiring a decree of mutual fault and divided damages.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.