Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit October 6, 1966, 30473_1 (United States v. Gerald Weisman)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-10-1966

PER CURIAM:

Appellant was convicted below on one count of knowingly receiving stolen property of the United States Government in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 641. The main question raised on appeal is whether there was sufficient evidence in the record below to uphold the conviction.

On appeal, appellant contends (1) that proof of his guilt was insufficient in law; (2) that a jury finding that he knowingly received stolen goods was contrary to the weight of evidence; (3) that the prosecutor improperly adduced proof of misconduct [false bill of sale furnished by appellant for a stolen rifle] unrelated to the crime charged; (4) that the prosecutor improperly referred to appellant’s failure to take the stand; and (5) that the prosecutor insinuated that he was being accused by defense counsel of suborning perjury.

At the trial, the Government introduced evidence that tended to show that two United States Army soldiers agreed to steal ammunition from Fort Dix; that on the particular day in question one of them, Allan P. Goldstein, picked up the ammunition in his car from a wooded area (where the other had deposited it earlier) and transported it to appellant’s gun shop; that appellant knew that he was dealing with a soldier; that in consideration for the ammunition appellant gave Goldstein a $60 check and a false receipt for a gun that Goldstein had stolen from the Army; and that the value of the ammunition was well in excess of $100. This evidence was sufficient to support the necessary inferences that the jury must have drawn in returning its verdict, namely, that the ammunition purchased by appellant was in fact stolen from the United States Government and that appellant was aware of its stolen nature.

The Government’s witness Goldstein testified that appellant had given him a false bill of sale (receipt) for a rifle which Goldstein had stolen, to give a semblance of legitimate ownership thereof by Goldstein.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.