Circuit Court of the 20th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Collier County March 18, 1966, No. 939 (State ex rel. Colding v. Tax Assessor)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-03-1966

HAROLD S. SMITH, Circuit Judge.

This cause coming on to be heard on the relation of the petitioner against Sam Colding, as county tax assessor of Collier County, and others; and the court having taken the testimony herein and examined exhibits and evidence submitted in this cause, and the court being advised in the premises, it is found, determined and adjudged as follows —

In the ultimate, this case has resolved itself down to the point where the questions of law are already determined. What remains for the court to find is the determination of the question of fact. The petitioner alleges that the respondent tax assessor was not following the constitutional mandate of assessing the property in Collier County at the values required by the constitution. The tax assessor alleges in his response to the petition that he was doing just that. It then became necessary for the court to hear the matter and to take testimony and examine the evidence to determine as a matter of fact whether the assessor was in fact assessing all property in Collier County, as required by the constitution, at just value.

The petitioner presented an imposing array of evidence which would tend to show that the tax assessor was assessing properties for a fraction of “fair market value” or “just value”, based upon the sales prices which were indicated by the public records and evidenced by the amount of documentary stamps affixed on the instrument in the public records. Scores of such sales were introduced by the petitioner and his contention was that these prices indicated on the sales of record should determine the fair market value. In turn, the assessor introduced evidence of many sales where the assessment exceeded the amount of the sales price, as indicated on the records by the documentary stamps.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.