Court of Appeals of Texas February 24, 1966, No. 14744 (Andel v. Eastman Kodak Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-02-1966

BELL, Chief Justice.

Appellants, who are husband and wife, sued appellee on their own behalf and as next friends for their two minor children, to recover damages allegedly resulting to Mrs. Andel and the children when the automobile Mrs. Andel was driving was in collision on March 6, 1964 with an automobile driven by an agent of appellee. Suit was for an amount exclusively within the jurisdiction of the District Court. Ap-pellee, in addition to its answer setting up a denial, contributory negligence and unavoidable accident, filed a counter-claim to recover damages to its automobile in the amount of $183.98. The basis of recovery on the counter-claim was negligence on the part of Mrs. Andel.

When the case was reached for trial, the appellants’ motion for continuance was overruled and they were required to proceed to trial. Appellants thereupon took a nonsuit. They then filed a plea to the District Court’s jurisdiction over the counter-claim, it being in an amount normally within the jurisdiction of the Justice Court. The plea was overruled and the trial was had to a jury on the counter-claim.

The jury found Mrs. Andel failed to yield the right-of-way; that she failed to keep a proper lookout; that she failed to make proper application of the brakes on her car, and that each act was a proximate cause of the collision. The jury also found the agent of appellee to have been guilty of certain specific acts of negligence which were each found to be a proximate cause of the collision. The court, therefore, rendered judgment that appellee take nothing on its counter-claim and assessed costs against appellee.

Appellee, in its brief, asks dismissal of the appeal on the ground that the judgment was entirely favorable to appellants and there is, therefore, nothing of which they can complain.

In the normal situation the rule asserted by appellee is correct.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.