New York County Courts June 7, 1966 (People v. Rizzo)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-06-1966
Martin M. Kolbrener, J.
An order signed by me permitted the police to tap and monitor the telephone wires of one of the defendants. From conversations thus recorded, the affidavits were made upon which the search warrant was issued. Upon evidence thus obtained, an information was later filed against the defendants in the District Court of Nassau County, charging them with the crimes of book-making, possession of book-making records, maintaining premises, etc.
Defendant’s motion brings up for examination the affidavits and the petition upon which I based the order permitting the wire taps. This type motion, in one respect, is similar to a motion to dismiss an indictment for insufficiency of proof before the Grand Jury. The moving party does not see the Grand Jury minutes and the motion may thus be granted or denied, depending upon the sufficiency of the proof before the Grand Jury. I have examined the affidavits and petition in the light of People v. McCall (17 N Y 2d 152, decided March 24,1966) and I find that the wire-tap order was based upon sufficient grounds; that is to say, that the sworn affidavit and petition show sufficient facts to constitute probable cause for the issuance of the order.
However, the motion is not so simply resolved. Defendant moves, not to suppress the evidence, but “to determine the admissibility in evidence of any wiretap evidence * * * obtained”. No allegation is made “ that the affidavit (upon which the order permitting the wire tap is based) is in fact either an error, incomplete or perjurious ”. Defendant claims that he is “ entitled to a hearing to prove, if he can, that such is the case.” (Emphasis supplied.)
I can understand that in situations where the burden of proof is on the other side, a denial of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief puts the other party to his proof (CPLR 3018) but here the burden of proving perjury, falsity and inaccuracy is upon the defendant (People v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit