Supreme Court of Pennsylvania March 22, 1966, Appeal, No. 359 (Bentman v. Seventh Ward Democratic Executive Committee)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-03-1966

lead-opinion

Opinion by

Mr. Justice Jones,

On April 28, 1964 — at a primary election — Donald W. Cox and Hedvah Shuchman were duly elected by a majority of the Democratic voters of the 6th and the *19010th Divisions, respectively, of the 7th Ward of Philadelphia as Democratic party committeemen from such districts. Their election was certified by the official election board and they were seated, without question, as members of the 7th Ward Democratic Executive Committee (Executive Committee).

On August 10, 1964, Cox and Shuchman were notified, in writing, that a meeting of the Executive Committee would be held on August 12, 1964, to consider and vote upon their removal as party committeemen. At that meeting, Harry Melton, then Democratic leader of the 7th Ward, charged Cox and Shuchman with having failed to act in harmony with the Executive Committee.1 The Executive Committee, allegedly by a 17-5 vote, voted to remove Cox and Shuchman as party committeemen. They were then removed from office and Melton appointed others to fill the vacancies on the Executive Committee.

Joined by two Democratic party electors who' had voted for them at the primary election, Cox and Shuchman instituted a mandamus action2 against the Executive Committee, Melton, the ward leader, and Francis E. Smith, Chairman of the Democratic County-City Committee.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.