Ohio Supreme Court January 26, 1966, No. 39334 (City of Akron v. Alexander)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-01-1966

lead-opinion

O’Neill, J.

The question before the court is whether Section 719.10, Revised Code, requires that a view of the premises by the jury be ordered in an appropriation proceeding when a party so demands.

It is clear that the city of Akron may take this property for an urban renewal project. It is equally clear that the city must pay compensation for the taking of such property. Section 19, Article I, Ohio Constitution. This compensation is the fair market value of the property at the time it is taken, as found by the jury, and the jury may not consider the fact that the value of the property has been increased by the proposal or construction of the improvement. Giesy v. Cincinnati, Wilmington and Zanesville Rd. Co. (1854), 4 Ohio St. 308. A corollary to this proposition is that the jury may not consider the fact that the value of the property has been decreased by the proposal or the construction of the improvement.

In the instant ease, the trial court made a finding, supported by substantial evidence presented at the hearing, that a view of the premises would be prejudicial to the rights of the property owner.

From a reading of the evidence presented, it appears that *77most of the buildings in the surrounding area had been razed and several of the remaining structures vandalized. The appellee’s buildings were, for the most part, vacant and had not been maintained since the commencement of the project. The property was undoubtedly of lesser value than it had been prior to the commencement of the project.

In 2 Lewis on Eminent Domain (3 Ed., 1909), 1330, Section 745, it is said:

“* * * If the proposed improvement had depreciated the value of the property, it would be very unjust that the condemning party should get it at its depreciated value, and the correct rule would seem to be that the value should be estimated irrespective of any effect produced by the proposed work.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.