District Court of Appeal of Florida November 15, 1966, Nos. H-474, H-475 (Johnson v. Williams)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1966

RAWLS, Chief Judge.

Plaintiff appeals from final judgments dismissing with prejudice his complaints in two wrongful death actions.

The factual allegations of both complaints are substantially the same and may be summarized as follows: The plaintiffs’ nine year old son was riding his bicycle along the street in front of defendants’ home when a dog began to chase him; he jumped off his bicycle and ran along the south side of defendants’ home in an attempt to escape the dog; in so doing, he ran into a wire cable which the defendants had stretched between two trees at a height of 3}/2 to 4 feet from the ground. He was thrown to the ground where he died of a broken neck and ruptured lungs. The complaints further alleged that the defendants knew that the neighborhood children frequently used this area on the south side of their house as a pathway to and from another neighbor’s basketball court and should have known these children might run into it.

Admittedly, the deceased minor child was a trespasser upon defendants’ home premises. A property owner owes no duty to a trespasser other than not to willfully or wantonly injure him. 23 Fla. Jur., Negligence, Section 24. This rule has been modified with respect to children of tender years by the adoption and application of the “attractive nuisance” doctrine *340by our courts. Justice Terrell, speaking for the Supreme Court in Carter v. Livesay, Window Co., 73 So.2d 411 (1954,) stated the rule applicable to the facts alleged herein ns follows:

“The test to be applied in a case of this type is whether a reasonably prudent person should have anticipated the presence of children or other persons at the place where the appellee created a condition that a jury could find was an ‘inherently dangerous condition’ or a ‘dangerous instrumentality’ like unto an explosive substance, and inflammable material, a live wire or a spring gun.” (Emphases supplied.)

In Switzer v. Dye, 177 So.2d 539, 541 (Fla.App.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.