District Court, Virgin Islands December 19, 1966, No. 161-1966 (Smith v. Hertz Rent-A-Car)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-12-1966

GORDON, District Judge

MEMORANDUM OPINION

The judgment of the Municipal Court of the Virgin Islands, Division of St. Thomas & St. John, was entered on November 3, 1965, in favor of the plaintiff. The appellant and appellee on April 15, 1966, filed a stipulation of facts and of issue at law. The appeal was brought on for argument on October 10, 1966, however the appellant and appellee stipulated to waive argument and submit the appeal upon briefs.

“The stipulated issue is:

In the matter of the appeal filed in the above matter by defendant

*686Hertz on November 12, 1965, the parties hereto stipulated as follows:

1. The matter appealed is the decision on the legal issue raised by defendant in his motion to dismiss to the effect that the complaint should be dismissed on the grounds that, while it alleges driving of defendant car with consent of the owner, it does not allege any agency between Hertz and the plaintiff, and that the complaint therefore does not state a cause of action against Hertz, and on the further grounds that Hertz is only a bailor for hire and the car cannot be sued ‘in rem’.

Reduced to an issue which was briefed by counsel and decided by the Municipal Court the specific question to be decided on appeal is:

Whether, assuming ownership of defendant car by Hertz, the driving of said car with the consent of owner Hertz at the time of the accident and the filing of the statutory lien on said defendant car pursuant to. the provisions of 20 V.I.C. § 542. Such a lien will lie to the extent that recovery may be had on said lien only, although there is no allegation of negligence on the part of the owner of the automobile, and the driver of the vehicle, although operating same with the consent of the owner was not, at the time of said operation the agent, servant or employee of the owner.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.