District Court, W.D. Michigan June 27, 1966, Civ. A. No. 4863 (Schenk v. Packaging Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-1966

OPINION

FOX, District Judge.

This is a motion for summary judgment brought by defendant Packaging Corporation pursuant to Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

Defendant Packaging Corporation claims that under the undisputed facts there is no basis for its presence in the case, since the driver of the vehicle involved in the accident which is the source of this suit was the employee of an independent contractor, and not an employee of defendant Packaging Corporation; it therefore following that no vicarious liability can attach to said defendant.

The court has carefully considered the briefs and the supplemental briefs filed by the respective parties on the theory of “economic realities” as having a bearing on possible changes in the decided law of Michigan pertaining to independent contractors.

Although the economic realities test has been applied in a number of cases involving social legislation, e. g., Tata v. Benjamin Muskovitz Plumbing & Heating, 354 Mich. 695, 94 N.W.2d 71 (1959); Schulte v. American Box Board Co., 358 Mich. 21, 99 N.W.2d 367 (1959), and Goodchild v. Erickson, 375 Mich. 289, 134 N.W.2d 191 (1965), the court is satisfied that the holdings in those cases at this time are limited to controversies arising under social legislation, which is to receive liberal construction and application.

While it is possible that the Michigan Supreme Court will at some time in the future apply this principle in the area of tort liability, at the present time the test for an independent contractor relationship is the right to control. Holloway v. Nassar, 276 Mich. 212, 267 N.W. 619 (1936); Marchand v. Russell, 257 Mich. 96, 241 N.W. 209 (1932); Dennis v. Sinclair Lumber & Fuel Co., 242 Mich. 89, 218 N.W. 781 (1928); Tuttle v. Embury-Martin Lumber Co., 192 Mich. 385, 158 N.W. 875 (1916).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.