District Court, S.D. New York December 8, 1966, Nos. 65 Civ. 787, 928, 923 (Fischer v. Kletz)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-12-1966

OPINION

TYLER, District Judge.

This is a motion by defendant Peat, Marwick, Mitchell & Co. (hereinafter “PMM”) under Rule 23(c) (1), F.R.Civ.P., as amended effective July 1, 1966,1 for a determination that none of the actions entitled Fischer v. Kletz (and fifteen other actions previously consolidated therewith), 65 Civ. 787, Bloch v. Nogg, 65 Civ. 928, and Garber v. MacKensen, 65 Civ. 923, are maintainable as class suits. In the alternative, defendant PMM asks that if it is decided that one or several of the actions are maintainable as class suits, the court should order plaintiffs in such actions to comply immediately with the notice requireents of Rule 23(c) (2) and (d) (2).2

*380I.

MAINTENANCE OF A CLASS ACTION

Plaintiffs in these actions purchased securities of Yale Express System, Inc., during the period between August 20, 1963, and either March 8, 1965 or May 6, 1965.3 It is their contention that various financial statements issued by the defendant Yale during this period falsely and grossly overstated figures purporting to represent the company’s earnings, revenues and forecasts thereof and that, as á result, plaintiffs purchased the securities at a false and inflated value and were thereby damaged. In each case, plaintiffs assert that their action is maintainable as a class action. For purposes of the following discussion, the “class” will be deemed composed of individuals who bought Yale securities in the form of either common stock or debentures between August 20, 1963 and either March 8, 1965 or May 6, 1965. Disagreement among plaintiffs as to the precise structuring of the class or classes will be disregarded except where specifically noted and the three actions treated as one.

Defendant relies upon four px'incipal grounds for contending that a class action cannot be maintained. First, it states that the class as presently defined does not meet the prerequisite of Rule 23(a) (2) that “there are questions of law or fact common to the class”.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.