New Mexico Supreme Court January 23, 1967, 8074 (Cochran v. Gordon)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-01-1967

OPINION

OMAN, Judge, Court of Appeals.

This is the second time this case has been here on appeal. On the first appeal the judgment in favor of plaintiffs-appellees was affirmed in all respects, except for the cross-appeal of plaintiffs taken pursuant to Rule 17(2) of the Rules of the Supreme Court of the State of New Mexico. Cochran v. Gordon, 69 N.M. 346, 367 P.2d 526. The cause was remanded to the trial court for the sole purpose of requiring an accounting by defendants to plaintiffs.

In the accounting proceedings which followed, the trial court found, just as was found on the prior trial, that plaintiffs had paid defendants for the partnership operations account the sum of $10,601.34. The trial court also found that one of the items, of expense incurred and loss sustained by the partnership was depreciation on certain pieces of partnership equipment in the total, amount of $2,962.42.

The defendants have appealed from the judgment entered at the conclusion of the accounting proceedings, and their sole point for reversal is stated as follows:

“THE BEGINNING POINT, TPIE INTERNAL CALCULATIONS, AND THE END RESULT OF THE TRIAL COURT’S ACCOUNTING HAVE NO SUPPORT IN THE EVIDENCE.”

They first attack the trial court’s finding that $10,601.34 is the amount which should be accounted for by the defendants. They predicate their attack upon the assertion that:

“ * * * the court ignored the uncontradicted evidence of the accountant that a total of only $20,263.68 (Ex. A. Tr. 39) had been paid by appellees toward both - the operating and purchase accounts, * * *»

[By deducting $12,001.34, the amount the court found on the first trial had been expended by plaintiffs toward the purchase of land, from $20,263.38, defendants arrive at $8,261.94 as the amount for which they claim they were required to account.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.