Wisconsin Supreme Court May 9, 1967 (Robert Hill Foundation v. Learman)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-05-1967
Hansen, J.
There are four issues raised on this appeal:
1. Did the county court follow the mandate of the supreme court in its conclusions of law and judgment?
2. Should the judgment be reversed in the interests of justice?
3. Was the finding of the market value of the real estate of $12,800 against the great weight and clear preponderance of the evidence ?
*93
4. Was it proper for the county judge to reject the affidavit of prejudice?
In its original opinion, this court specifically stated that the question before the court did not resolve itself on whether or not the executor acted in good faith and was honest as to the manner in which he handled the sale of the real estate. The real question is whether or not the executor fulfilled his duties as a fiduciary while acting in his capacity as such. The opinion correctly stated that good faith alone in the performance of the duties of a fiduciary is not sufficient.
Estate of Martin
(1963), 21 Wis. (2d) 334, 341, 124 N. W. (2d) 297. The grant of the power of sale to the executor imposed upon him a special confidence,
a discretion cowpled with a trust to be exercised solely for the benefit of the cestuis que trust. Scheibe, supra.
The
Scheibe
decision cites considerable authority as to the duties of a person occupying a position of trust such as an executor. All of the authority holds executors to the duty of exercising such diligence and caution as a careful and prudent owner would observe in the sale of his own property.
The record now before the court as to the facts and circumstances surrounding the sale of the real estate is the same as on the original appeal. No further evidentiary hearing was held. The entire emphasis of the first opinion reflects a considerable doubt as to whether the executor acted as a reasonable and prudent man with loyalty to the beneficiaries. The salient facts are contained in the first opinion.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit