Dade County Small Claims Court March 25, 1967, No. 159806 (Habersin Camera Shops, Inc. v. American Express Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-03-1967

SIDNEY L. SEGALL, Judge.

Final judgment is rendered in favor of plaintiff for $780 (including interest) plus costs in the sum of $12.40.

The material facts are not in dispute. The plaintiff is a holder for value of $600 worth of traveler’s cheques.

Plaintiff is an operator of a camera shop in Miami. In the usual course of business plaintiff sold a camera and camera equipment to several different customers who presented certain traveler’s cheques sued on herein, in payment for said merchandise. The checks were completed in each instance except for the counter signature in the lower left hand comer thereof. The *98customers represented themselves to be the rightful owners and bona fide purchasers of said checks by the presentation of identification cards of the persons represented in the “sign manual” (in the upper left hand corner). The counter signatures at the time of the purchase were then executed in the presence of the plaintiff by the purchasers of the merchandise.

The evidence is uncontroverted that the checks in question were stolen and negotiated by impostors. No negligence on the part of the plaintiff herein is alleged by the defendant. In fact, the counter signatures appear almost perfect imitations of the signatures in the “sign manual”.

Plaintiff, in substance, contends that he is entitled to recover, even though the counter signature was forged and cites in support of his position American Express Company v. Anadarko Bank and Trust Company, 179 Okl. 606, 67 P.2d 55.

In that case the bank cashed certain traveler’s checks for a customer, which had been allegedly stolen from an agent of the American Express Company. The Anadarko Bank and Trust Company was also an agent for the American Express Company and owed the express company certain monies for the sale of traveler’s checks made by the said bank in the ordinary course of business. The American Express Company demanded payment for said traveler’s checks sold by Anadarko and the bank refused to pay.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.