Court of Appeals of Texas January 13, 1967, No. 4144 (Angelina Casualty Company v. Russell)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-01-1967
COLLINGS, Justice.
Dale Blanton Russell brought suit against Angelina Casualty Company to recover benefits under the Workmen’s Compensation Act. The trial was before a jury which found plaintiff entitled to compensation benefits in a lump sum and $381.00 for necessary medical expenses. Based upon the verdict, judgment was rendered against the defendant. Angelina Casualty Company has appealed.
Appellant’s first three points complain of the action of the court in permitting appellee’s wife, Mrs. Russell, to stand before the jury and display the deformity of her lower limbs over appellant’s objection, and in overruling appellant’s motion for a new trial because of alleged prejudicial and inflammatory argument to the jury by appellee’s attorney in connection with such deformity. Appellant’s objection to the display to the jury was in substance as follows:
We object to any further questioning along this line. It is evident that this didn’t occur at the paper mill and no suit has been brought for it. The only issue upon which it could be material would be the question of lump sum and we think the fact that she has had an operation and is unable to work should be sufficient without trying to influence the jury by any demonstration in the court room.
In our opinion no reversible error is shown. The condition of Mrs. Russell’s leg and foot had been testified to by Mr. Russell without objection. Mrs. Russell also took the witness stand and testified concerning the condition of her foot and leg and which were observed by the jury. It does not appear that there was anything about Mrs. Russell’s appearance as shown by the exhibition or demonstration complained of other than what was described by the unobjected to testimony of Mr. and Mrs. Russell. Appellant’s first point is overruled.
In his closing argument appellee’s counsel made the following statement in reference to Mrs. Russell:
“Oh, that hurt them real bad you know, that we mentioned about this deformed woman.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit