Louisiana Court of Appeal April 17, 1967, No. 7005 (Duet v. Texas Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-04-1967

SARTAIN, Judge.

Plaintiff appeals from an adverse judgment in the district court rejecting his demands for personal injuries arising out of a boat-pipe line collision.

On or about February 23, 1954, at about 10:00 o’clock a. m. plaintiff was operating a trawler type boat named the “Captain Vic”, owned by his father, Donatien Duet, when he struck a submerged pipe line near Bay Ste. Elaine in the Parish of Terrebonne. The rear one-third of the boat struck a four inch high pressure gas line owned, installed, and operated by the defendant, The Texas Company, resulting in an explosion of the line and a hole in the bottom of the boat, causing the latter to settle to the bottom in very shallow water.

The primary dispute of facts herein concern the location of the collision and the depth of the water. The trial judge found that the collision occurred 100 to 150 feet from an existing channel in which appellant was supposed to operate his vessel and that the depth of the water at the point of collision was about 18 inches. The record clearly supports the trial judge’s finding of fact in these respects. We quote with approval from his written reasons:

“The record shows that The Texas Company dredged a canal 6 or 7 feet deep and about 70 feet wide across a shallow bay leading to several drilling locations in the Bay Ste. Elaine area, for the purpose of transporting equipment and men in its operations, and that a 4-inch high pressure gas line was laid on the far side of the levee away from the canal. The testimony indicates that the rigs were about 1,000 feet or less apart along the canal; and that piling marked the location of the canal in the vicinity of the rigs and three or four 2x4 stakes marked the canal location between each rig. The spoil from the canal excavation was dumped on one side at a distance from the canal the length of the boom on the dredge. The spoil bank was estimated to be from 60 to 70 feet wide.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.